The Origins of the GUI
“What I saw in the Xerox PARC technology was the
caveman interface, you point and you grunt. A
massive winding down, regressing away from
language, in order to address the technological
nervousness of the user.”
- An IBM technician lambasting the Apple Lisa’s GUI
Once upon a time, way back in the Stone Age, lived
two cavemen, Ugh and Glug. Ugh was a handsome,
sportsy, outdoorsy type, with a stunning physique
and the mental capacity of a waterbug. His pal Glug
was just the opposite: nervous, toothy, skinny
(except for the little pot belly he’d earned from
eating too many delivery pizzas), and smart. Damn
smart. One day, while Ugh was out hunting game and
posturing for the caveladies, Glug was sitting
morosely in his cave, absently scratching under his
loincloth and telling himself that he was not
jealous of that lout Ugh. Directly over his head, a
chunk of rock trembled and shook as it pulled free
from the ceiling. It snapped free and dropped
directly onto Glug’s pointy head with a thunk.
When Glug awoke, it was to the annoying feeling of
water being sluiced into his face, and the equally
annoying scent of Ugh’s aftershave Mammoth Musk.
Ugh was bent over him, concern in his perfect blue
eyes. “Glug okay? Rock whack Glug.”
Glug shoved his friend out of the way and said,
“Give Glug room! Must think!” Glug dashed from the
cave and into the grassy meadow beyond the cave
entrance. Panting, he snatched up shards of coconut
shells, wads of tall grass, smooth flat rocks, and
several mammoth bones left over from breakfast. He
lugged his haul inside the cave and, almost as an
afterthought, picked up the rock that had knocked
him unconscious earlier. Ugh looked wonderingly at
his friend, then went outside to stare at bugs (he
was endlessly fascinated). With a pointy stick,
Glug began to draw strange diagrams in the dirt.
Ugh peeked inside hours later and, seeing his
friend engrossed in his odd cave drawings, shrugged
and went to the third cave over to spend the
evening with his ladyfriend Oohlala.
Days passed. Ugh quickly learned to stay out of the
cave, as Glug snarled and threw bits of rock and
coconut shell at him if he entered. Besides, it was
more fun staying with Oohlala. On the fourth day,
Glug came outside for the first time. He squinted
at the harsh sunlight, then motioned for Ugh to
come inside. Ugh shoved Oohlala off of his lap and
followed his friend inside the cave.
In the corner, hidden by a bearskin, was a squarish
object. Dull light seemed to come from underneath
the animal skin. Wonderingly, Ugh approached the
object, ready to bolt at the first odd noise or
threatening motion. Glug said, “Ugh behold!” and
whipped the bearskin off of the object.
Whatever it was, it was built of coconut husks and
pieces of mammoth bone, with a large hollowed-out
coconut shell sitting atop the large, flattish hunk
of rock that had brained Glug earlier. Hanks of
grasses were twisted together and shoved into the
backs of the various objects. A flat rectangular
rock covered in tiny river barnacles sat in front
of and slightly below the main body of the object,
connected to the main housing with a braid of
grasses. Dark light poured from the large,
centrally placed coconut shell. Ugh stared in
fearful awe at Glug’s creation.
“Look, Ugh!” Glug exclaimed. “Glug build wonder
thing!” As Ugh gaped, Glug hunched over the flat,
barnacle-studded rock and began poking it,
apparently at random. But…lines, tiny bright green
ones, appeared in the dark light of the coconut
shell. Apparently the more Glug poked at the
barnacle-covered flat rock, the more the green
lines appeared in the shell.
After a few moments, Ugh began to grow impatient.
Oohlala was waiting outside, after all. “What good
this thing?” he asked. “Not good to eat. No good
for wearing in snow. Maybe good for whacking
mammoth….”
“No, no, no!” Glug snarled. “Can do things. Count
mammoths Ugh kill. Watch.” He began to poke the
barnacle board in short, sharp jabs, and one by
one, lines appeared in the shell. “One…two…here one
you kill last month…here one that you chase over
cliff…here one that washed up in river…” He kept
poking, and finally he stopped. “See? Ugh kill
seventeen mammoths since first thaw. Good to know,
uh?”
Ugh was interested, despite himself. “Can Ugh use?”
Glug motioned him to sit in front of the shell and
placed Ugh’s dirty fingers on the barnacles. “Okay,
Ugh pay attention. First, must log in.”
“Log in?”
“Log in…we create Ugh a user name. We call it…Ugh.”
Over Ugh’s shoulder, Glug poked at the barnacles,
to Ugh’s mounting confusion. “Now Ugh can get in
system. Good. Now we go to C: prompt….”
“See prompt? Where? Ugh confused.”
“Ugh wait. Good, we in. Now we access file
directory.”
“File directory? User name? See prompt?” Ugh shoved
himself away from the strange object and stood up,
towering angrily over Glug. “Glug confuse Ugh! Make
head hurt! You want Ugh to use strange thing, give
Ugh pretty pictures! Bright colors! Point and
click, not barnacles and see prompts! Ugh leaving!”
Ugh shoved Glug aside and made his way to the cave
entrance and outside. He failed to notice that he
had shoved Glug too hard, and poor Glug went
reeling headfirst into the cave wall. For the
second time in a week, Glug’s skull impacted solid
rock.
It was dark outside when Glug finally awoke. Ugh
was nowhere in sight. Glug sat up, cradling his
injured head in his hands. “Whoof, head hurt big
time,” he muttered to himself. “But Glug have
better idea!” He found his pointed stick and began
drawing in the dirt again. “Him want bright colors,
pretty pictures, Ugh, him get bright colors, pretty
pictures. Glug call it…Graphical User Interface.
But Glug not tell Ugh that. Him hardheaded as cave
bear, fancy name scare Ugh. What me call it?” Glug
thought and thought. Finally he decided to go for
the simple, straightforward approach. “Ugh make
baby talk OK,” Glug thought. “Just stick with baby
noises. Glug call it…GUI. Gooey. Even Ugh smart
enough to say that one. Gooooooeeeeeey.”
“"There is no reason anyone would want a computer
in their home." ”
“– Ken Olson, President, Chairman and Founder of
Digital Equipment Corp., 1977”
The story is part of the computer world’s
mythology. December 1979, an ordinary afternoon:
young computer whiz and entrepreneur Steve Jobs
leads a band of his homeys into the rarefied
enclave of Xerox’s Palo Alto Research Center
(PARC). Jobs and friends tour the plant with
wide-eyed admiration, doing their best Norman
Rockwell gee-whiz kids-in-the-dugout impression
(“Golly, Dr. Kay, can we have your autograph,
huh?”), while behind guileless eyes and
black-framed glasses, mental notes are being taken
and schematics memorized.
Jobs leads his friends out of the building, waves
bye-bye to the nice lab geeks inside, and dashes
back to his shabby warehouse, where he and cohort
Steve Wozniak stuff every idea and process they can
remember from the Xerox tour into their new
product, the Macintosh. Xerox is befuddled,
Microsoft’s Bill Gates is enraged, and Apple gets
the jump on everyone with a new dance craze, the
GUI. “Do the GUI” sweeps the computer world and
everybody else scrambles to get on the gravy train.
Gates takes Jobs’ thievery one step beyond Jobs’
own and brings out Apple-clone Windows, Microsoft
does a pas de deux with the local judiciary to
dodge an Apple lawsuit, Windows takes over the
world, and Apple is relegated to cult status among
the renegade hackers and Mac addicts of the
computer industry.
Nice story to read your kids to sleep with. It has
everything: drama, criminal behavior, ruthless
rivalry between former associates, everything
except sex (which the stereotyped computer geeks
are unfamiliar with, anyway). Hell, it would even
make a good David Allen Coe drinking song. The only
problem with it is that it isn’t true.
The Real History of the GUI
The real history of the Graphical User Interface is
more complex and interwoven than the simplistic “It
Takes a Thief” conception.
“"So we went to Atari and said, ‘Hey, we’ve got
this amazing thing, even built with some of your
parts, and what do you think about funding us? Or
we’ll give it to you. We just want to do it. Pay
our salary, we’ll come work for you.’ And they
said, ‘No.’ So then we went to Hewlett-Packard, and
they said, ‘Hey, we don’t need you. You haven’t got
through college yet.’" ”
“– Apple Computer Inc. founder Steve Jobs on
attempts to get Atari and HP interested in his and
Steve Wozniak’s personal computer”
From Small Seeds…
Apple was founded by Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak
in Jobs’s garage in 1976. Jobs and Wozniak met at
Hewlett-Packard and began their collaborative
careers by building (Wozniak) and selling (Jobs)
“blue boxes” illegal devices that scammed free
phone calls from Ma Bell. Both shared an interest
in the “primitive” computers of the time and
enjoyed cobbling together electronic goodies with
solder and breadboards. Eventually they decided to
start a company and build computers that wouldn’t
take up an entire basement, didn’t need
supercooling, and didn’t require platoons of guys
in jumpsuits to take care of them. In other words,
they envisioned building personal computers for the
masses. Of course, neither Jobs nor Wozniak were
the first to think of personal desktop-sized
computers (common wisdom gives that honor to the
MITS “Altair,” a 1975 kit-based creation running
Microsoft’s BASIC OS and based on Intel’s 8080
chip), but that’s another story. They put their
heads together and decided to call their company
Apple.
In March 1976, Wozniak built the first Apple, the
Apple I. It was a cobbled-together curiosity made
of circuit boards and LED displays stuffed into a
wooden box, but it stirred enough interest in the
computing community to inspire Jobs and Wozniak to
found Apple on April Fools’ Day, 1976 to sell their
little beasties. Jobs sold his VW minibus, and
Wozniak his HP scientific calculator, to finance
the startup. They only managed to sell about 200 of
the Apple I’s, so the fledgling company now
consisting of Wozniak, Jobs, and a few
friends/employees used the money they managed to
raise from Apple I sales to start work on the Apple
II (Wozniak has reputedly said that a large part of
his desire to build the Apple II was due to
“Breakout,” a classic video game he had designed
for Atari. Wozniak wanted to program it for a PC).
In 1977 the Apple II debuted, featuring a sleek
plastic case (as opposed to the “orange crates”
that houses the Apple I’s), game paddles, and color
graphics on the video display. Being descendants of
Ugh, people were fascinated by the bright colors
and the flickering images, and the Apple II began
to move off the shelves.
Jobs realized that he had started something that
could mushroom into a serious business concern, and
he laid on more employees, more workspace, and
buckled down to the task of meeting the sudden
consumer demand for his goodies. When Apple added
the inboard floppy disk in 1977 (abandoning the
slow and clumsy tape storage facility), the II’s
sales really took off, and Apple was suddenly at
the crest of a wave of interest in personal
computing. Never mind that many novices bought an
Apple II without a clear idea of what to do with
it… the mere concept of the average Joe being able
to own and operate a “personal computer” was
catching people’s imaginations.
“WILL SOMEONE PLEASE TELL ME WHAT A PERSONAL
COMPUTER CAN DO? ”
“– 1982 Apple Computer ad”
Which brings us to Jobs’ infamous trek to Xerox’s
PARC facility. Actually, we need to look further
back in time to set the stage for Jobs’ visit.
The 40s – GUI Forefathers: Bush and Engelbart
Let’s back up to 1945 (!) and a visionary named
Vannevar Bush. Bush, a scientist and futurist, went
public with his ideas of the “memex,” a computing
device that would use what we’d call hyperlink
technology to bring information to every user’s
fingertips.
Bush’s ideas sparked some visionary thinking in a
scientist named Douglas Engelbart. As early as
1962, while Jobs and Wozniak were still drinking
Ovaltine and watching Saturday morning cartoons in
their jammies, Engelbart was creating several items
of interest to the personal computing crowd that
would follow. He invented the first “mouse,” which
he called an “X-Y Position Indicator,” a little
gizmo housed in a wooden box on wheels that moved
around the desktop and took the cursor with it on
the display. Engelbart saw the mouse as being an
integral part of a “graphical windowed interface,”
and invented what he called "a windowed GUI" that
fascinated co-workers but wasn’t considered useful
outside the lab. In 1968 Engelbart created NLS
(oNLine System), a hypermedia groupware system that
used the mouse, the windowed GUI, hypermedia with
object addressing and linking, and even an early
version of video teleconferencing to wow its
audience, a group of technicians, engineers, and
scientific types at Stanford University.
However, Engelbart was not the only visionary in
the history of GUI. In 1963 a grad student at MIT,
Ivan Sutherland, submitted as his thesis a program
called “Sketchpad,” which directly manipulated
objects on a CRT screen using a light pen.
“"Sketchpad pioneered the concepts of graphical
computing, including memory structures to store
objects, rubber-banding of lines, the ability to
zoom in and out on the display, and the ability to
make perfect lines, corners, and joints. This was
the first GUI (Graphical User Interface) long
before the term was coined." ”
“- from a Sun Microsystems biography of Ivan
Sutherland”
The idea of direct manipulation of objects on a
screen is integral to the concept of a graphic
interface. In fact, the idea of a GUI derives from
cognitive psychology, the study of how the brain
deals with communication. The idea is that the
brain works much more efficiently with graphical
icons and displays rather than with words words add
an extra layer of interpretation to the
communication process. Imagine if all the road
signs you saw were uniform white rectangles, with
only the words themselves to differentiate the
different commands, warnings, and informational
displays. When the “Stop” signs hardly look
different from the “Resume Highway Speed” signs,
the processing of the signs’ messages becomes a
slower and more difficult process, and you’d have
even more wrecks than you have now.
Combine this with Alan Kay’s concept of “biological
computing,” where computer components function like
organic “cells,” either independently or in concert
whenever appropriate, and you have an idea of the
thinking behind both modern computing, and the GUI.
The 70s – SmallTalk and Xerox
“"The best way to predict the future is to invent
it." ”
“– informal PARC slogan”
The underground buzz stayed underground, but
Engelbart’s and Sutherland’s creations were not
lost on the creative fellows at Xerox’s PARC
facility. PARC was (and is), at least in some
respects, a computing “think tank,” where brilliant
and brilliantly erratic minds cranked out ideas and
tried, with varying success, to implement them on
the workbench.
In the early 70s, as part of a (sadly abortive)
project called “Dynabook” that envisioned
notebook-sized, hyperlinked computers, Alan Kay and
others developed an interactive object-oriented
programming language called Smalltalk. Kay had
previously worked with a team at the University of
Utah that developed a programming system called
Flex. This was a design for a flexible simulation
and graphics-oriented personal computer, with many
ideas derived from the Norwegian-developed Simula
programming language, another programming language
called LISP, and Sutherland’s Sketchpad. Kay also
borrowed ideas from a highly graphical language
called Logo, which was designed to teach
programming to children. Smalltalk featured a
graphical user interface (GUI) that looked
suspiciously similar to later iterations from both
Apple and Microsoft.
Smalltalk didn’t stop with an innovation in user
interface: it featured a multi-platform virtual
machine years before the folks at Sun came up with
Oak/Java, object orientation, overlapping
“windows,” and the first instance of bit-blt or
"bit-blitting," the last two contributed by Dan
Ingalls (the object-oriented language featured in
ST actually showed up in the Simula-67 program in
the late 1960s; “bit-blitting,” or bit block
transfer, is, in simplistic terms, the protocol by
which objects on a screen can be manipulated). A
lot of observers feel that ST’s clean, easy-to-use
interface has yet to be surpassed even today. The
first program to be written under Smalltalk was
Pygmalion, which is most notable for its
demonstration that computer programming could be
graphically based and not restricted to text. The
idea of using icons to stand for data was reflected
in Pygmalion.
The first real-life, usable GUI appeared in Xerox’s
Alto computer, which debuted in 1974 and was
envisioned as a smaller, much more portable
replacement for the mainframes of the time. The
Alto, which didn’t have a GUI as you and I are used
to using, but instead featured graphically driven
applications, was about the size of a Volkswagen
(well, not quite, but the thing was big) and
certainly not useful for the average user, even
though it started its life showing an image of
Sesame Street’s “Cookie Monster.” The Alto featured
a bit-mapping display, which was essential for
displaying graphics and WYSIWYG printing. Kay,
David Canfield Smith, Bill Verplank, and others
also developed iconic representations for various
programs for the Alto, most noticeably the drawing
program “Markup,” the text editor “Bravo,” and the
painting program “Superpaint.”
In 1981, the design and concepts which gave birth
to the Alto led to the development and production
of the much more streamlined, and more usable Xerox
Star the first true GUI-driven PC. According to
Bruce Horn, an ex-Xerox employee who wound up
working for Apple, the software architecture for
Smalltalk and the Star were much more sophisticated
than the Mac or Windows equivalents. While the
Apple machines incorporated much of Xerox’s
brainstorms, many of the most innovative and
sophisticated ideas never made it into the Apples,
mostly due to Apple’s insistence on keeping costs
down. The Star featured the first “computer
desktop,” as well as overlapping, resizable
windows, and the sophisticated PARC mouse, a
gee-whiz gizmo that ran with no moving parts and
used laser beams and a metal grid to track the
cursor’s movement (though employees found that the
mouse worked just as well on Levis as it did on the
metal grid). The interface was known as WIMP
Windows, Icons, Menus, and Pointers. PARC’s
consensus was that once these ideas were
implemented on a wide scale, computing efficiency
would increase dramatically.
1979 – Apple Visits PARC
Jef Raskin, a project manager with Apple, first
told Jobs and Wozniak about the research being done
at PARC. It’s a mistake to envision this scene as
taking place in some deserted parking garage, with
Raskin hiding in the shadows and doing his best
Deep Throat impersonation. A closer scenario is
that Raskin wanted to work more directly on a GUI,
and dropped a bug in Jobs’ ear about the neato
keeno work being done at PARC. Jobs was reluctant
to go at first, but eventually Raskin, who wrote
his master’s thesis on a WYSIWYG graphical
interface back in 1967 and was seeing some of his
ideas brought to fruition by the folks in PARC,
piqued his interest.
At any rate, Jobs, who was first told by Raskin
about the fun going on at PARC in 1976, decided
that he wanted to bring a team of Appleniks into
PARC and see what was causing such a buzz but
again, the idea of Jobs coming in like a kid
touring Epcot with a tape recorder hidden under his
shirt is mistaken. Apple negotiated a deal with
Xerox; in return for a block of Apple stock, Xerox
allowed Jobs and his team to tour PARC in December
1979, take notes, and implement some of the ideas
and concepts being bounced around at PARC in their
own creations. I’m not sure how Xerox felt about
Apple subsequently hiring half perhaps the better
half of PARC’s staff away from them, but the
process was relatively above-board; no night
kidnappings or bribes under the table at Jack In
the Box. Xerox allowed Apple to use their ideas in
their machines. As Wozniak says on his Website,
“Steve Jobs made the case to Xerox PARC execs
directly that they had great technology but that
Apple knew how to make it affordable enough to
change the world. This was very open. In the end,
Xerox got a large block of Apple stock for sharing
the technology. That’s not stealing outright.”
“"The reason why Jobs got the reputation of being
so brilliant in human-centered computing is because
he neglected to tell anyone at PARC that his
perceptive questions about GUIs and so on were
drawn from his discussions of such things with
Raskin at Apple a month or two earlier. He
masterfully made it appear as though he was
encountering bitmapped GUIs for the first time in
his life instead of having discussed them with
someone who had visited PARC himself." ”
“– Neil Franklin”
At any rate, Jobs and the Apple guys came back from
their PARC tour with stars in their eyes. They were
entranced with the idea of a “windowing GUI” and
loved the flexibility and power of Smalltalk. They
had a new vision, and were determined to unleash it
on the computing world ASAP. Development
immediately began on the Apple “Lisa.”
1979 – Birth of Apple Lisa
Lisa is worth a paragraph or two on her own. Jobs
and his buds envisioned Lisa (named for the
original chief engineer’s daughter, and also
standing for Local Integrated Software
Architecture) as the first of a new, GUI-based PC
family, but developed her primarily for business
use. It’s notable that the new product line came on
the heels of the 1981 failure of the Apple III
line, which was so flawed that it had to be
recalled. Apple had some ground to recoup. The Lisa
line featured the warhorse Motorola MC68000
microprocessor which trundled along at 5MHz,
boasted 512K of RAM (upgradable to 2MB), had every
bell and whistle that the Apple design team could
stuff inside her, and cost more than $10,000. Lisa
was rather large and clunky, though many veterans
of the PC wars insist that she is still one of the
most efficient and usable machines of her type ever
built.
Initial development on Lisa began before the 1979
field trip to PARC (Raskin says that Lisa was first
envisioned as a text-driven PC along the lines of
the Apple II), but she didn’t appear on the market
until January 1983. Eventually the cheaper,
pared-down Lisa2 appeared, but neither sibling did
well on the market they were too expensive, and the
Apple II family was still riding high on the
market, even with the competition from other
machines like the Commodore 64 and VIC-20, the IBM
PC, and the Radio Shack TRS-80. Even later, after
the Macintosh had begun to take the PC market by
storm, Apple decided to unload some of their Lisa
stockpile by repackaging it as the “Macintosh XL.”
The buyers weren’t fooled, and many Lisas ended up
in a California landfill. Interestingly enough,
Lisa featured a set of integrated software called
“7/7,” that included a word processor, a
spreadsheet, chart builder, outline manager,
project scheduler, drawing program, and modem
communication utility. 7/7 may well have been the
first integrated “works” package.
“"A few months after looking at it [the Xerox Star]
we made some changes to our user interface based on
ideas that we got from it. For example, the desktop
manager we had before was completely different; it
didn’t use icons at all, and we never liked it very
much. We decided to change ours to the icon base.
That was probably the only thing we got from Star,
I think. Most of our Xerox inspiration was
SmallTalk rather than Star."”
“– one of the Lisa development team”
Jobs and the Lisa design team worked hard to
integrate the Xerox/PARC concepts they had obtained
into their own design. Lisa’s GUI was, indeed,
based on Smalltalk as it ran on the Alto, but much
of Lisa’s design was Apple’s own, including
click-and-drag capability, and the pull-down menu —
this according to Jef Raskin, who headed the
Macintosh design team and should know, but other
sources give the credit for click-and-drag and
pull-down menus to PARC. Whether this is another
example of PARC’s ideas being implemented at Apple,
or it’s an example of side-by-side independent
development is uncertain. As they say, it
steamboats when it’s steamboat time. Apple also
worked with psychologists, artists, teachers, and
ordinary users to improve their interface. In one
famous example, Apple provided a California
elementary school with free machines for every
student’s use. During the summers, the Apple
programmers worked with the teachers and kids to
enhance the software and the GUI, because they felt
that kids gave the truest reaction to basic
interface issues, e.g. “These menu things are
cool!” or “That picture sucks!”
“"The [Lisa] user will be able to carry out many
functions simply by pointing to a picture of what
he wants done rather than typing instructions." ”
“– Time Magazine, 1983”
1983 – Mac Arrives
Jobs was no longer the only alpha male in the Apple
pack (if he ever was). John Sculley, the corporate
executive brought in to reshape Apple into a
“grown-up” business, took Jobs off the Lisa project
because of Jobs’ poor project management skills,
and turned him loose on the next Apple project, a
slimmed-down and considerably cheaper “daughter” of
Lisa, eventually to be known as the “Macintosh.”
The Mac was named for team leader Jef Raskin’s
favorite strain of apple, but spelled differently
in order not to offend audio manufacturer McIntosh.
Under development since September 1979, the Mac
lost much of Lisa’s bulk and price tag (the first
Mac sold for $2500), and was the first popular PC
to feature a graphical user interface. The Mac also
bundled MacPaint, which brought computer “art”
design to the average user (and not unimportantly,
sold the average user on the mouse), and MacWrite,
a simple word processor that was the first WYSIWYG
product of its kind on the consumer market.
Raskin left Apple in 1982, but the Mac team labored
on, and the Mac hit the market in January 1984,
heralded by the famous “1984” commercial that aired
during the Super Bowl and depicted the Apple PC
demolishing the gray, faceless world of IBM
computing. Prophetic. Many average users fled
screaming from the aggravating world of the DOS
command line to the friendly Mac GUI, and while
power users and DOS fans dismissed the Mac as a
Playskool product, the Mac’s user-friendly
interface made friends throughout all levels of the
computing community. Later iterations of the Mac
boosted the underpowered 128K of RAM, giving it the
gumption it needed to compete with the button-down
IBM machines. In 1986, Aldus released its desktop
publishing app, PageMaker, for the Mac, and the Mac
suddenly became everyone’s PC of choice for graphic
arts and desktop publishing. GUIs were all the rage
(later made even more tasty by the addition of
color displays in the Mac II), the Mac ruled the PC
universe, Microsoft was scrambling to catch up, and
all was right with the world. Even though Jobs had
been forced out of Apple in May 1985 by no-fun CEO
Sculley, Apple was riding the tiger.
There are supposedly reliable sources that claim
everything original in the Macintosh was cooked up
at PARC and transposed wholesale into the Mac;
other equally “reliable” sources claim that the Mac
is virtually a homegrown Apple creation, with very
little influence from PARC-generated concepts. Both
ideas are wrong; it’s plain that the Mac is a
product of intense cross-fertilization between both
creative sources. As Raskin says, “The years of
study, thinking, and experimentation by many
talented people on the Macintosh project and
elsewhere have gone largely unreported, though they
led to the breakthroughs that made the Macintosh
and the systems that have been built since its
introduction so much of an improvement over what
went before. Against this complex reality we have
the powerful mythological image of Jobs drinking
from a Well Of All Knowledge, having an ‘aha!’
experience and coming back at full cry to Apple to
create a fantastic project.” In fact, the Lisa owes
more of a creative debt to the PARC designs than
does the Mac. Many of Lisa’s features were borrowed
wholesale from PARC, down to the fonts and their
nomenclature. As Raskin notes, “We were somewhat
more pure while I was running the Mac project.”
“"The future lies with a graphical windowing
interface, mouse cursor control, pull-down menus,
dialog boxes, and the like [and computers based on
such interfaces] are destined to take over the IBM
PC and compatible world as well." ”
“– W.F. Zachmann, 1987”
In the Meantime at Microsoft…
Meanwhile, in the Pacific Northwest, a great evil
was stirring… Oh, please. To cast Microsoft and its
head honcho Bill Gates as the Great Satan, or as
Sauron to Apple’s brave little band of hobbits, is
ridiculous. Both co-founders, Jobs and Gates, are
much more alike than they are different. Neither
one is a lily-white altruist just trying to bring
personal computing to the masses, nor is either a
black-moustachio’ed villain bent on destruction.
While I doubt either Jobs or Gates would recognize
a code of ethics if it hit them in the mouth,
neither one belongs on the Ten Most Wanted List,
either. Both wanted to carve out a place for
themselves in the PC market, both were willing to
cut corners to get what they wanted, and both were
tremendously successful at what they did.
“"640K ought to be enough for anybody." ”
“– Bill Gates, 1981 (possibly apocryphal)”
Microsoft began just as small and insignificantly
as Apple did. Starting out as a two-man operation
out of the backseat of Bill Gates’s car, Gates and
cohort Paul Allen saw the MITS Altair and in the
span of a month had a BASIC interpreter ready to go
for the beastie. The code wasn’t tested until they
demonstrated the program for MITS, and Allen’s
first time even touching an Altair was when he
inputted the code into MITS’ machine. MITS bought
the product the first programming language written
specifically for a personal computer and Allen
joined MITS as Director of Software. By July ’75,
BASIC 2.0, a Microsoft creation, was running the
new, more powerful Altairs. The name “Microsoft”
wasn’t chosen until November ’75.
“ALLEN: "We would almost always overestimate our
competitors’ ability to compete."”
“GATES: "Or we’d assume that they were going to
execute competently."”
“– from a 1995 interview with Bill Gates and Paul
Allen”
1977 – Microsoft and Apple Team Up
Allen rejoined Microsoft in time to christen the
company’s new offices in Alberquerque. In early
1977 Microsoft licensed “AppleBASIC” to Apple for
the flat fee of $21,000, which turned out to be a
steal of a deal, as Apple sold over a million
computers with AppleBASIC running the show (Wozniak
actually wrote the integer BASIC for the early
Apples). By the end of 1979, Microsoft had
participated in porting both FORTRAN and COBOL
languages to microcomputers, moved to Washington
State, entered into agreements with ASCII
Corporation of Japan, and expanded into Europe. The
two-man operation was now employing 40 people and
bringing in over $7 million. Microsoft’s congenial
association with Apple continued into the 1980s,
with Microsoft bestowing the Z-80 SoftCard upon
Apple in 1980. The SoftCard allowed the Apple II to
run most of the CP/M programs currently featured on
most smaller computers.
Interestingly, Microsoft was working out the
details of a secret deal between themselves and Big
Blue for a new operating system, which they called
DOS (Disk Operating System). MS-DOS (which was
spawned from an operating system called Q-DOS
written as a CP/M knockoff by Seattle Computer
Products, and bought by Paul Allen in 1980)
appeared as the operating system for the first IBM
machine, the IBM PC, in August 1981. Since Gates
had insisted on keeping the rights to MS-DOS for
his company, he was able to license the operating
system to any number of “clone” computer and
application manufacturers. IBM made an effort to
keep DOS to themselves by releasing machines that
ran their own version, PC-DOS, but with Microsoft’s
willingness to license MS-DOS to all comers, PC-DOS
never caught on. As late as 1993, IBM was still
trying to market PC-DOS as a viable alternative to
the Microsoft operating systems, but by then DOS
was waning in market appeal mass-market users liked
the various GUIs and had little use for further
command-line interfaces) At the end of 1981, Steve
Jobs paid a visit to Microsoft to give them a look
at the embryonic Mac, and authorized Microsoft to
develop apps for the new, GUI-based system. From
1981-1984, Microsoft folks were all over the Apple
labs, working alongside Apple techs to develop
applications for the Mac. In the process, Microsoft
acquired an intimate familiarity with the inner
workings of the Mac design.
A note on the above: Microsoft’s DOS 1.0 code
structure was virtually a clone of Digital
Research’s CP/M 1.4 operating system…one source
calls it a “bug-for-bug” copy. Digital Research
(DRI) began working on an updated version for
16-bit computers called CP/M86, to be used with
machines featuring Intel’s 8086 processor;
unfortunately for DRI, CP/M86 wasn’t ready for
prime time when IBM came looking for an operating
system, and they went with Microsoft’s DOS instead.
In 1982, Digital Research finally released CP/M86,
and converted it to their own DR-DOS system in
1987. Digital Research sued Microsoft over the CP/M
DOS imbroglio, but the lawsuit fizzled. One source
very hostile to Microsoft alleges that Microsoft
did their level best to sabotage DR-DOS when it was
released, including making spurious claims that
Windows would not run under DR-DOS, as well as
hustling their own updates to MS-DOS onto the
market to cut the legs out from under Digital
Research’s product, and using illegal marketing
practices to force PC manufacturers to use their
own system in lieu of DR-DOS.
Naturally, this isn’t the only version of this
story, but the bare facts are that DR-DOS never
impacted the market in the way that Microsoft’s
competing MS-DOS did, at least partially due to
Microsoft’s energetic and possibly underhanded
attempts to push their own system over DRI’s.
Digital Research later sold DR-DOS to Novell in
1991. After attempting to integrate it into their
own Networking Operating System and releasing
versions under the name “Novell DOS,” Novell sold
it to Caldera in 1996, almost three years after
Novell’s final attempts to work with DR-DOS.
Caldera transformed DR-DOS into an open-source
product, called OpenDOS. Caldera also sued
Microsoft for illegal marketing practices over the
DR-DOS affair, and Microsoft settled the lawsuit
out-of-court in January 2000. Had CP/M86 been ready
for use when IBM came calling, it’s possible that
Microsoft would never have gotten the “in” with IBM
that propelled it to glory, and we’d all be cussing
Digital Research today, instead of Microsoft. Who
can say?
Two months before the Macintosh officially hit the
market, in November 1983, Microsoft announced that
it was working on its own GUI-based operating
system (actually, a “shell” that rode atop the DOS
OS) to be known as “Windows” (which Gates wanted to
call “Interface Manager,” but slicker heads
prevailed). Microsoft had already caused a stir in
April ’83 by giving a “smoke-&-mirrors” demo of
their prototypical Interface Manager, using
overlapping windows to simulate multiple programs
running simultaneously. IBM executives were not
happy with Microsoft’s little toy, as they were
working on their own DOS-based program manager, to
be called “Top View.” Gates had tried repeatedly to
interest IBM in Windows, and was rebuffed each
time; IBM felt that the interest in GUIs was a
passing phase. Top View was released in 1985 and
discontinued in 1987; its graphical interface
influenced IBM’s much more noticeable OS/2, even
though a GUI-driven version was never made public.
Windows 1.0 made its official debut almost two
years after it was announced, in November 1985.
Apple was stunned by the similarities between the
Mac and Windows interfaces, but as there were
almost no applications available for the Windows
environment (Aldus’s PageMaker for Windows was a
notable exception), Win 1.0 came and went on the
consumer market without much fanfare. The failure
of Win 1.0 to capture a decent market share, along
with plateauing Mac sales, caused some to wonder if
the GUI craze was a fad that had peaked.
Ironically, in light of the bad blood to come
between the two companies, Microsoft’s Excel (a
GUI-based spreadsheet that was similar to its
predecessor VisiCalc, but easier to use) gave the
Mac much-needed viability at this time.
1983 On – Other GUIs Hit the Market
Were the Mac and Windows GUIs the only ones on the
market? Hardly. In fact, the first
consumer-oriented, PC-based GUI was made not by
either company, but by VisiCorp, the makers of
VisiCalc. Called VisiOn, it debuted in October
1983, shortly before the Lisa, but was crippled by
the lack of popular software written to run under
it. The same story can be told of DRI’s GEM
(Graphical Environment Manager), which appeared in
September 1984 and disappeared shortly thereafter,
partially because it, like VisiOn, lacked the
ability to run DOS apps, and had no software of its
own. Worse luck for GEM: Apple didn’t like GEM’s
similarity to the Mac desktop, and threatened to
sue. Rather than fight, DRI revamped the GEM
desktop to get Apple off its back. Both VisiOn and
GEM had their proponents, but neither made a major
dent in the consumer market, which continued to be
dominated by the twin monoliths Apple and Microsoft
.
And there was Quarterdeck’s DESQView, the first
program to bring multitasking and windowing
capabilities to a DOS environment. DESQView wasn’t
a full-fledged GUI OS, but its GUI “shell” over DOS
won many fans and intrigued many folks at
Microsoft, including Gates, who by some accounts
based his first iteration of Windows as much or
more on VisiOn, GEM, and DESQView than on the Mac
interface (this conflicts with the stories passed
around the campfires of the Apple fans, who portray
Gates as a petty thief who snarled to his Windows
team, “Make it look just like a Mac!”). Berkeley
Softworks’ GeoWorks (GEOS) is another GUI OS worthy
of note; it was used on the Commodore 64, some
Apple IIs, and still survives in an altered form as
software for the PalmConnect system. GEOS was
lauded as a slick, stable operating system, but the
lack of software for it developer software did not
appear for six months after GEOS’ debut ensured
that most PC users never gave it a second thought.
Apple was not happy at all with Windows. Even
before the system appeared on the shelves, Apple
was threatening Microsoft with lawsuits that
alleged patent infringement, intellectual theft,
what have you. In an ingenious move, Microsoft
signed a licensing agreement with Apple that stated
Microsoft would not employ Apple technology in
Windows 1.0, but made no such agreement for further
versions of Windows. It took a while for Apple to
realize that Microsoft had thoroughly skunked them;
the realization took longer to hit because of
Windows’ dismal failure on the consumer market.
Nevertheless, both Apple and Microsoft forged ahead
with their own plans for world domination…er,
rather, their plans to expand their niche of the PC
market. As always, though, these two were not the
only bands marching in the parade. In 1985
Commodore launched its Amiga line of home PCs, and
won the hearts of millions of users. The Amiga was
the first PC to truly introduce the idea of
“multimedia” into PC-dom, although since most users
didn’t know what to make of their new multimedia
capabilities, they played games on it instead.
Great-looking games. Amiga’s advanced sound and
video capabilities went along with its
sophisticated GUI-driven OS (which also featured
preemptive multitasking, shared libraries,
messaging, scripting, multiple simultaneous line
consoles, a real use for the right mouse button,
and other features not found in the Apples and IBMs
of the day). To add insult to injury, Amiga
featured Apple/IBM interface emulation. Apple or
IBM users who preferred their old interface could
have Amiga mimic that look instead of its own.
So why didn’t Amiga wipe both Apple and
IBM/Microsoft off the PC market? As usual, we have
a patchwork of reasons. The best guess is that
Amiga made the same mistake as the Tucker passenger
auto made… it was too far ahead of its time too
fast, and couldn’t take advantage of its own
capabilities. The heated competition that existed
between Amiga and Atari worked to Microsoft’s
advantage, as did Amiga’s spotty ability to keep
their dealers and customers happy. Adding to
Amiga’s problems were the first machines’ failure
to settle on a single GUI (one Amiga user tells me
that the early models had different interfaces
depending on which program was running). But
whatever the reasons, Amiga was one sharp puppy,
and deserved a better fate though today Amiga is
neither gone nor forgotten; a new OS called “The
Digital Environment” is being touted as the next
step in GUI-driven operating systems. We may hear
from Amiga again before all is said and done.
Yet another mid-80s contender in the GUI wars was
the Atari ST. Atari, much better known for their
video games, produced a PC that featured the GEM
OS. Like the Amiga, the ST couldn’t compete with
the big boys, nor could it compete with Amiga for
gamers, but its sophisticated sound processing
capabilities earned it a niche with audio editors
and musicians.
Sometime around the debut of the Amiga, the first
UNIX GUI appeared as well. Many UNIX heads had long
sneered at the simple-minded, overly convoluted
operating systems and playtoy PCs that were
populating the consumer market. But some UNIX users
decided to see if they could overlay a GUI on UNIX
in the same fashion as Microsoft overlaid Windows
atop DOS, and thus X was born. X (sometimes called
“X Windows,” and sometimes incorrectly called “X
for Windows”) was born at MIT, fathered by a
Stanford University windowing system called W and
mothered by Sun’s “SunView” environment. X became
the main graphics system for most RISC-based UNIX
operating systems. While X was a well-written and
easily handled OS shell, it never settled on a
particular “look and feel,” and as a result at
least three different interfaces, or “windows
managers,” floated around for it.
This isn’t the main reason why X never caught on
much outside the UNIX community, but it’s certainly
one reason. X is still a viable GUI shell, and has
a relatively small but vocal following. X is making
something of a resurgence among UNIX users: the
battle between “windows managers” has shaken itself
out, the interfaces are more polished and easier to
use, and it’s very useful for high-end computer
graphics production. X is also the underlying GUI
for most Linux graphical interfaces. The “several
GUIs” are more correctly known as the various *nix
windows managers, and users can run desktop
environments such as Gnome or KDE for additional
functionality. X-driven interfaces are popping up
in such non-PC devices as TiVo, Web pads, and PDAs,
and one X user speculates that as these devices
become more widespread, we may see X actually being
used more than either Apple or Windows GUIs.
It’s also worth mentioning that Three Rivers
Computing Company manufactured a graphics
workstation called PERQ in 1981 that incorporated a
UNIX-based GUI, and was marketed in the U.K. by
ICL. This GUI actually predates all of the above,
including VisiOn, but as far as I know, it was
never made available for personal computers.
Completists will point out that IBM’s MVS (Multiple
Virtual Systems) mainframe system included an
optional program known as ISPF (Interactive
Structured Programming Facility) that allowed
split-screen windows to be supported on terminal
displays. Considering that ISPF was created in the
late 1970s, it’s one of the first “windows-like”
systems that became available. Of course, it’s
highly unlikely that home PC users would have ever
seen this.
It’s worth noting that many, many
graphically-driven applications were released
independently of any of the abovementioned systems.
One of the very first was Bill Budge’s Pinball
Construction System, which appeared in 1985 for the
Atari and quickly became famous among both gamers
and programmers for its sophisticated ability to
manipulate objects using click-and-drag. Programs
like PCS made their mark on the operating systems
that followed them into the PC marketplace.
““I had an enormous reservoir of goodwill towards
Microsoft because it and it alone unlike Xerox,
Apple, Amiga and many others who tried before it
was the one that finally delivered a usable
graphical interface on ubiquitous, inexpensive
hardware. Microsoft often wasn’t the first, and its
software wasn’t often the best, but it was
inarguably the one that delivered on the early
promise of personal computing in a way no other
software maker did. Microsoft more than any other
company opened up computing for ordinary people. I
loved Microsoft for that.” ”
Fred Langa
Back to the big guys. December 1987 saw the release
of Windows 2.0, to the consternation of Apple but
the yawns of the consumer. Although Win 2.0 looked
more like the Mac than ever, with icons
representing files and programs, cascading windows,
and the like, Mac users weren’t leaving the Apple
flocks to buy the IBM/Windows machines (especially
since the hunky Mac II’s were all over the
shelves). Apple hemmed and hawwed a few more
months, and finally sicced the long-threatened
lawsuit on Microsoft, claiming that Windows stole
the Macintosh’s “look and feel.” 1988 saw the
market all but ignore Apple’s GS/OS for the Apple
IIGS, but the Mac continued to dominate the market.
By 1989, the general buzz was that Windows was a
mammoth flop. Microsoft continued to work with IBM
in developing the fully graphical OS system, but
kept pounding on Windows, hoping to eventually get
one version right. As the cliche says, “even a
blind squirrel finds an acorn every now and then.”
It was about to be acorn time in Redmond.
Windows in the 90’s
“"I think Windows 3.0 will get a lot of attention;
people will check it out, and before long they’ll
all drift back to raw DOS. Once in a while they’ll
boot Windows for some specific purpose, but many
will put it in the closet with the Commodore 64." ”
“– John Dvorak, 1990”
A great, orchestrated hullabaloo welcomed Windows
3.0 to the market in May 1990. Steve Ballmer led
the chant of “Windows! Windows! Windows!” at
Microsoft HQ in Redmond, Washington; the great
beast that was, and is, Microsoft’s marketing
machine took care of the rest of the world.
Microsoft unveiled dozens of applications written
specifically for Windows at the same time it
released the new version of Windows, which now
featured the OS/2 style “sculpted buttons” credit
to icon designer Susan Kare for the much more
appealing button styles; Kare also worked on the
Mac more color support, real multitasking, and a
much-improved program manager, among other things.
These new features and fresh software releases
finally got the market’s attention. Impelled by the
popularity of its own Win-compatible versions of
Word and Excel, and numerous other 3rd party apps,
Microsoft sold over 3 million copies of Win 3.0 in
its first year of release, and Apple was feeling
the chill. Win 3.1 (April ’92) added scalable
TrueType font support and better multimedia
capabilities, and Apple was on the run. For the
first time, Windows-equipped PCs were outselling
the Macs. Windows 3.1.1, called "Windows for
Workgroups," did relatively well in the corporate
world, as well as bequeathing much of its design to
later versions of Windows.
1993 saw the first version of Windows NT (New
Technology), which abandoned the crash-prone kernel
of its predecessors for a new, much more stable
kernel. NT started out as a new version of IBM’s
OS/2 system, part of Microsoft’s and IBM’s joint
venturing. It was originally known as OS/2 3.0 or
OS/NT, but during early development, Microsoft and
IBM split, and Microsoft walked away with the
program, combining IBM’s OS concepts with their
own, rewriting the code, and eventually releasing
it under the Windows umbrella. Problem was,
Microsoft marketers couldn’t decide what to do with
it. Obviously it was more useful for business
usage, so, being Microsoft, they tried to sell it
to anyone but business users. It quickly became
known as “Windows No Thanks”, and catty observers
decided that Microsoft had shot itself in the foot.
Not so fast… it turns out that a lot of people who
were using Unix had decided to give NT a go, and
liked what they saw. By early 1995, many European
corporations had shifted over to version 3.5, the
second “official” version of NT. By mid-1995, NT
had established itself among technical and business
users, and by the time the “bulletproof” (read:
virtually crashproof) version 3.51 was available,
Win NT was firmly entrenched. NT worked very well
in the corporate and office environment, but less
so in the home: it wasn’t engineered to run older
DOS-based software, which made it the wrong choice
for gamers and folks with less-than-cutting edge
software.
The lawsuit wasn’t going well, either. Apple’s
strategy was to prove that Windows had illegally
copied the “look and feel” of the Mac GUI, but that
strategy sprang some significant leaks after the
Microsoft lawyers pointed out that both systems
“borrowed” liberally from the original Xerox
concepts. To Jobs’ accusation of theft, Gates made
the damning retort, “No, Steve, I think it’s more
like we both have a rich neighbor named Xerox, and
you broke in to steal the TV set, and you found out
I’d been there first, and you said, ‘Hey, that’s no
fair! I wanted to steal the TV set!'” The fact that
Windows’ interface design looked, if anything, more
like the old Alto GUI than the Mac designs didn’t
help Apple’s case. Suddenly Microsoft was the buzz,
and Apple seemed to be yesterday’s news.
Apple’s Torrid Ride
The long-running lawsuit was finally settled in
Microsoft’s favor in June 1993, and the doomsayers
thought that Apple’s fate was sealed. Wozniak and
Jobs were long gone. The company was in financial
trouble (though the reports of imminent bankruptcy
were wrong). Their long-anticipated “Newton”
personal data assistant was a bust. Management
seemed more interested in fighting among themselves
than righting the company. Orders went unfilled due
to production problems. Some predicted that Apple
would fade into complete irrelevance when, in
August 1995, Microsoft unveiled its groundbreaking
Windows 95 OS. Win 95, the first operating system
to take advantage of Intel’s powerful 32-bit chips,
and a near-clone of the Mac GUI, seemed to be the
irresistible force destined to finally run Apple
out of business once and for all. Apple tried to
recoup by pushing its “Performa” line of low-end
PCs (basically older, repackaged Macs) over its
higher-end “PowerPC” line, and failed miserably
Performas sat gathering dust in the Apple
warehouses, while buyers found it difficult, if not
impossible, to get hold of the PowerPCs they
wanted. More and more first-time users chose
Windows-driven PCs over Apples, in large part
because the fierce competition between the
Windows-clone manufacturers were keeping the
Windows machines’ prices relatively competitive,
while Apple’s relentless refusal to let others
manufacture clones (only partially loosened in 1994
and yanked in 1999), its embarrassing
quality-control problems, and its comparatively
high sticker prices, soured many buyers on the
Apple name. Microsoft’s decision to slap a modified
version of the Win 95 interface onto Win NT 4.0
boosted the NT platform’s popularity, and detracted
that much more from the Apple market share.
In October 1994, IBM tried unsuccessfully to yank
some of Microsoft’s market share with the third
version of its own operating system, OS/2 Warp.
OS/2 was originally a Microsoft/IBM joint venture,
but Warp was IBM’s own offering, and featured a
Windows-like GUI. It managed to stay afloat and win
some loyalty, but it never really became anything
more than a weak alternative for IBM-machine users
who didn’t want to use Windows. And while we’re on
the topic of weak alternatives, now’s the time to
give a sardonic nod to Microsoft Bob, the
“next-generation” GUI that rode atop of Windows and
“assisted” novice users with a happy, chatty,
virtual assistant named Bob. Bob tanked hard, and
became a figure of fun among the computer
cognoscenti. His only legacy was the equally
annoying Office Assistant, the “dancing paper clip”
that currently plagues Microsoft Office.
“"Software is getting to be embarrassing." ”
“- Alan Kay”
Meanwhile, Apple wasn’t cored just yet. Steve Jobs
had founded a company called NeXT, and while the
NeXT computer failed in the marketplace, the sleek
and sophisticated NeXT OS (an OS built on the UNIX
MACH kernel and featuring a fabulous GUI) was quite
attractive to Apple. Apple’s Mac operating system
was showing its gray hairs, and Apple wanted
something new and glitzy to throw up against
Microsoft’s monolithic offerings. In December 1996,
Apple bought out NeXT, thus acquiring NeXTStep,
elements of which would turn up in the new Mac OS,
Rhapsody. Jobs came along for the ride, and it
wasn’t long before he was again at the helm of the
company he had founded.
Apple fans weren’t happy with the return of their
hero for long. In August 1997, Jobs announced a
formal liaison with Microsoft, to the dismay of the
rank and file. Microsoft bought $150 million of
Apple stock, and both companies agreed to once and
for all end the GUI dispute. Many disgruntled Apple
users, already disturbed by Apple’s continuing
inability to build enough machines to fill orders,
along with Apple’s failure to license the Apple
system to clone manufacturers, leapt off the Apple
bandwagon once and for all; it’s no coincidence
that the new surge of interest in “alternative”
OS’s such as Be and Linux began about the same time
as Jobs’ perceived “sellout” of Apple to Microsoft.
Certainly the ex-Apple minions fleeing their former
home didn’t start the Linux/Be/etc. buzz, but they
made their contribution, especially when Apple
yanked its support from the Be platform, originally
designed to run on the PowerPC.
Note, though, that most Appleniks didn’t dive
overboard solely because of the “sellout” of Apple
to Microsoft. The more knowledgeable in the Apple
community understood that Microsoft’s commitment
meant more stability for Apple, as well as
continued development of MS Office for the Mac.
Microsoft’s $150 million purchase was a small
fraction of the Apple stock base, and Microsoft’s
shares were strictly non-voting. According to some
stories, Apple fans had a reaction similar to a
church congregation whose preacher announced that
Beelzebub was being named as head deacon. But the
real reasons why so many Apple fans were
disaffected are much more complex.
Apple gained ground with the successful release of
the Mac OS 8 “Platinum,” a popular and stable OS.
Unfortunately, some of that ground was lost in the
confusion that followed OS 8. The original idea was
to give Apple users a “next-generation” system to
be called Copland. Instead of releasing it in
mid-1996, Apple squelched the project in favor of
working with the newly acquired NeXT OS. Apple then
announced a new system under development, Rhapsody,
which would combine elements of the NeXT OS on top
of a UNIX core. The aforementioned OS 8 appeared in
July 1997, and featured some of the more touted
elements from Copland. Rhapsody also failed to
materialize, and eventually transmogrified into the
OS X project, announced in May 1998. An upgrade to
the “Platinum” system, OS 9, was released in
October 1999. The next-generation OS X was finally
released for the PC in March 2001, and many of the
features promised for Rhapsody appeared in this
system.
In 1998 Apple reinvented the PC market with the
now-ubiquitous iMac. The iMac, withas its cutesy
color scheme and user-friendly design, won the
hearts of many users and the scorn of many
reviewers. “Serious” Apple users gravitated to the
ever-more powerful PowerMac line, but millions
chose to perch the cute little iMacs on their
desks. Along with the modestly successful PowerMac
and PowerBook laptop/notebook PCs, the iMac gave
Apple the recharge it so badly needed. The iMac
comes with either OS 9 or OS X installed. The trend
of other folks copying Apple continued, with
Daewoo’s eMachines drawing Apple’s fire for looking
and acting like the iMac. This time Apple
prevailed.
Today…
In Redmond, Microsoft barrels along. Its
hyped-to-the-max release of Windows 98, launched in
June 1998, failed to live up to expectations. Most
users, who were led to expect a revolutionary new
product, were annoyed when Win 98 proved more of an
upgrade than a groundbreaking new product. Feelings
are much the same about Windows 2000, or “Win 2K,”
the latest and last iteration of the NT line, and
even more so about Windows Millennium, which after
all the ballyhoo settled, turned out to be little
more than a minor upgrade to Win 98. Microsoft is
betting its OS fortunes on its integration of the
9x and NT lines in its upcoming Windows XP system.
Microsoft hasn’t fared so well in its latest court
outing, with the Department of Justice doing what
Apple was unable to do, obtaining a ruling that
Microsoft was a monopoly and was acting against the
best interests of the market and the competition
(though as I write this, the DOJ has abandoned its
attempts to break up Microsoft). Apple continues to
push their latest iteration of the Mac OS, OS X,
and promises a new version, 10.1, by the time you
read this. Both corporations are poised to continue
their dominance of the PC market for the
foreseeable future, though UNIX fans remain firm
and Linux is steadily gaining ground.
And the future of the GUI? Well, considering that
well over 90% of the world’s users employ one
GUI-faced OS or another, considering that new
GUI-driven OS’s such as Be seem to be catching on,
and considering that this season’s darling, Linux,
is usually used with any of several GUI’s from
Caldera, Corel, and Red Hat, among others, the
future for the GUI seems secure. Comrade Gates and
others have proposed a much more “involved”
interface, with voice recognition, touch screens,
retinal and fingerprint scans for security,
holographic representations, and virtual “avatars”
that interact with the user much more directly
than, say, that damned MS Office paper clip. Ugh
would be pleased. I’m not sure what Glug would
think.
Note: I am indebted to the many people who
responded with commentary, corrections, and
criticism of the original version of this article.
In particular, Jef Raskin was of enormous
assistance through the revision process; I
appreciate both his cooperation and his patience.
The many respondents on the Slashdot message boards
were also very helpful, as were the dozens of
people who took the time to e-mail me with their
own commentary and enlightenment. Thanks to one and
all.
MT, September 7, 2001
http://www.sitepoint.com/real-history-gui/