A few years ago, Apple sold me a $4,000 computer
with a defective graphics chip/logic board. The
defective part was the Nvidia 8600M GT GPU, and
when it was discovered that the machine was
defective, Apple refused to take it back and issue
me a refund. Instead, they promised to replace the
8600M GT boards when they failed, up to 4 years
from the date of purchase.
Three years later, the board failed, and
predictably, Apple refused to replace it. Instead,
they used the fact that the machine wouldn’t boot
(due to the failed logic board) to deny the repair.
Not only that, but in addition, they tried to
charge me a hefty sum of money to have it replaced,
knowing full well that Nvidia pays for the full
repair cost.
Three and a half months ago,
after having my repair denied, I announced on
this very site that I was going to sue
Apple. Reading these lawsuit threats
often, many people assumed that I was bluffing
or blowing off steam, but true to my word, I did
exactly what I said I was going to do. I sued
Apple.
I did not take this step lightly, however. In the
months following the announcement, I did everything
in my power to keep my dispute with Apple out of
the court system.
First, I filed a complaint with
the Better Business Bureau. In their
rebuttal to the BBB, Apple blatantly lied about
the diagnostics they had run on my computer, and
the BBB promptly closed the case, leaving
Apple’s “A+” rating intact.
Next, I spoke with Apple Executive Services … three
separate times. Each time, I was told that “We
value each customer and hope that they have a
positive experience with Apple, and are sorry that
you did not have this experience, but you will get
nothing.” … or something to this effect.
After that, I sent a demand letter to Apple via
certified mail. I informed them that if I did not
have my issue resolved within 10 days, I would sue.
Only then, after Apple failed to
reply, did I file a Small Claims
lawsuit.
Last week, the trial was held.
I arrived at the King County Courthouse shortly
after 8am, and about forty five minutes later, the
clerk performed roll call. Imagine my surprise when
I learned that Apple had sent not one, but two
people to represent the company. When Apple told me
that I would get nothing, they really meant it.
After calling roll, and before calling the docket,
the clerk went down the case list and asked each
litigant if they would be willing to try mediation.
Mediation keeps cases out of the court system, and
keeps the outcomes confidential. This is especially
beneficial to companies, as having judgements
issued against them by customers is bad PR.
Always one to exhaust all good-faith remedies
before resorting to more drastic measures (really,
nobody can say I didn’t try my hardest to stay out
of court), I agreed to try mediation, and to my
surprise, so did Apple.
Since everything said in the mediation room is
confidential, I cannot go into details about what
happened there, but I will tell you that it failed,
and the case was sent back to the courtroom.
In retrospect, I am glad that mediation did fail.
After seeing that Apple sent two guys … two guys
who were in continuous contact with Apple legal via
text and cell … I knew that I was outgunned,
outspent, and out-everything elsed.
$500,000,000,000 vs. $37 and a pack of chewing gum
is not a fair fight. Because of this, I offered
settlements that were ridiculously favorable to
Apple and unfavorable to myself, but even these
were rejected. Thank goodness that they were.
After failing mediation, shortly after 11am, we
were called before the judge, sworn in, and I read
my opening statement. I said basically everything
I’ve been saying on this blog for the last several
months. I stuck to the facts, handed my exhibits to
the clerk (several printed pages), and was as
professional as possible.
When it was Apple’s turn, their representatives
opened by throwing a hail mary pass. While holding
up the press release outlining the 8600GT
replacement program, they claimed that, because the
CPU in my MacBook Pro was clocked at 2.6Ghz, and
not 2.4Ghz, or 2.5Ghz as stated in the release,
that I had a completely different computer … one
that was not subject to the 4 year replacement
program.
You see, when I ordered my MacBook Pro, I paid
about $300 extra for them to up-clock the chip from
2.5Ghz to 2.6Ghz. Yes, it was a classic Apple
ripoff, and yes, I was dumb to order it, but I did
it, mea culpa.
I had absolutely no idea that it would be used
against me in a court of law to explain to a judge
why I should not be covered by an extended
warranty, and it caught me off-guard. Perhaps,
despite everything, I am still a bit naive, because
not even I expected Apple to just … lie. At least
not in such a silly manner.
Remember, I was not going up against the owner of
some taco stand, I was up against the most
profitable company in the USA. I honestly expected
more than a silly fib.
After listening to Apple, the judge turned to me
and asked for my response, and I explained to him,
in detail, that the chips, logic boards, and GPUs
in all of the MacBook Pro models were the same,
regardless of the speed at which the CPUs had been
clocked.
Confused, the judge turned to Apple and asked, “Is
this true?”
There was some awkward silence as the Apple guys
exchanged uncomfortable looks between each other,
before one of them finally said “Yes, it is.”
“So, this machine IS covered by the 8600GT repair
program?”, asked the judge.
“Yes it is, your honor”, replied Apple.
So, there we were. Not more than 2 minutes into the
trial, and Apple conceded to trying to hoodwink the
judge.
This is more or less the way the rest of the trial
played out. I made a point, Apple rebutted it with
something completely off-the-wall and irrelevant,
and I explained to the judge why Apple’s rebuttal
was nonsense. I took the time to explain everything
clearly, I answered all of the judge’s technical
questions in detail, and at one point, the judge
even declared that he would accept my testimony as
that of an “expert witness”.
Apple, well, they didn’t really have a defense.
They just kept repeating things like “It’s Apple’s
policy to do this”, and “It’s Apple’s position that
we do that”. The Apple guys seemed genuinely
surprised that I knew as much as I did about
computer hardware. I’m not trying to insult
iPeople, at least not in this article, but during
both mediation and the trial, I realized that Apple
has a strong expectation that their users not be
tech-savvy and, as such, Apple seems used to
infantilizing and bamboozling their customers with
silly and nonsensical explanations of highly
technical matters.
Years ago, I remember debating the Mac vs.
Everything Else issue with a friend of mine, and
every time I would bring up the relative attributes
of a particular component, he would always respond
with
“Specs don’t matter!”
I thought he was just being stubborn, but after
this experience, I realize that this type of “I
don’t care about gigahertz and whatchamajiggers, I
just know that Macs use pixie dust and purple
elephant dung to make magic!” mentality is a part
of the Apple culture from the top down. From the
lowest-level sales rep all the way up to the
corporate guys.
As the trial went on, I showed the judge evidence
that the 8600M graphics cards were known to be
defective, I showed him that I had an 8600M in my
machine, and I explained to him that, despite their
promise to do so, Apple refused to replace my board
because it would not boot, and it would not boot
because the 8600M had failed.
The judge accepted these explanations, and when he
asked Apple what it would cost to replace my logic
board if I paid in cash, I interjected and
explained to the judge that if Apple replaced only
the logic board, it would simply be another logic
board with a defective GPU, therefore, such a
solution would not be acceptable.
The judge responded by asking Apple if my machine
could be fitted with a different GPU, and when they
replied “No, that machine will only accept an 8600M
GT”, the judge declared my make & model of
MacBook Pro to be defective and unrepairable by any
means.
Eventually, over the continued objections of the
Apple folks (one of the guys kept arguing that I
should give Apple one last chance to fix it), I was
awarded a cash amount. The amount I was awarded is
enough to replace the computer, which means that I
should once again have a 17″ laptop. Assuming Apple
actually pays me.
Now, I didn’t get everything I asked for. When I
filed the suit, I was pissed off, so I asked for
the kitchen sink … a refund of Apple Care (which I
only purchased when I learned the machine was
defective), compensation for loss of use, and even
some punitive damages.
Had I been able to show loss-of-use damages, I
probably would have gotten them, but the judge
awarded what would “make me whole” … essentially,
putting me back in the same place that I was before
Apple wronged me. This being the case, I received
compensation for the machine itself, plus court
costs, costs of service, etc.
It was a fair ruling, a little more than I expected
actually, and I thanked the judge.
The Apple guys, well, they were none too happy. By
the time I stood up, they had already beat a hasty
path to the courtroom door. I was going to offer my
hand, thank them for their time, and explain that
it was nothing personal, but they weren’t
interested in any of it.
And that was that.
I guess what they say is true. The sun even shines
on a dog’s butthole every now and then, and on this
day, I got myself a nice tan.
David faced Goliath, and not unlike the AT&T
case a couple of months ago, David somehow,
someway, came out on top.
Even though I’m glad it turned out the way it did,
one question still nags me:
Why?
Why did it have to come to this?
At one point, the judge asked Apple how much it
would have cost them to have simply replaced my
logic board when I had taken it in, and one of the
Apple guys said “Oh, it wouldn’t have cost us
anything, Nvidia foots the bill for each board we
replace.”
The judge’s face almost hit the floor as he shot me
a quizzical look, to which I just shrugged. I knew
that he, and everyone else in the courtroom was
thinking the same thing:
If Apple could have replaced my logic board at no
cost to themselves, then why in the hell did they
drag this out for so long, and why did they send
two people to court to try and make sure that I got
absolutely nothing? Friends, this is a question I
have been asking myself for three months, and it is
a question that I do not have the answer to.
You know, I fully respect a person or a company
that stands up for himself/itself when they are in
the right. It’s the correct thing to do.
What I don’t understand, however, is why Apple
fought so hard against me when they were clearly in
the wrong. It wasn’t even a judgement call. I knew
they were wrong, the judge knew they were wrong,
the clerk knew it, the audience knew it, and you
could tell … you could just tell that Apple knew it
as well.
And what of the shareholders? What should they make
of this? Apple’s stock has been an E-ticket ride
lately, but this incident should really give
shareholders pause. I mean, what kind of judgement
are the current leaders of Apple using?
Think about it … instead of repairing my computer
under the repair program that they, themselves,
announced … at absolutely no cost to themselves …
Apple paid two guys to come to Downtown Seattle,
and … well … lie, so that I would not have a
non-defective computer. When you factor in the time
it took them to get here, the time spent in court,
and the time to get home, Apple paid two guys a
day’s wages to defend this suit.
In addition, instead of paying nothing for the
repair, they paid a legal team to oversee the case,
and, oh yeah … you guys, the shareholders, are
buying me a new computer too. Thanks.
As far as I can tell, Apple spent all of this time
and money, solely to be a bully. Was that really
money well-spent? I mean, you can almost excuse the
holy wars against Adobe, Samsung, Android, and the
prototype guys … but a local blogger?
The obsessiveness of crushing all perceived
enemies, no matter how big or small, regardless of
whether they are wrong or right, should be of
concern to all iFans and financiers. It’s getting
to the point where it’s really, really just sick.
Gone are the days of the scrappy underdog, throwing
a hammer through the window of conformity, and what
has emerged is … well, it’s far worse than what it
was rebelling against.
Apple has become the Orwellian nightmare that it
warned us about some 30 years ago. A huge vehicle
of sameness backed by legions of newthink
practitioners, gleefully cheering as Big Bully
annihilates one thoughtcriminal after another.
Apple may be profitable, but it’s not well.
Something is wrong at the highest levels, and if I
was strongly tied to the company financially, I
might be worried. Although blinded by Apple’s
success in the near-term, I don’t think history
will judge the company favorably.
Anyway, now comes the hard part.
Collecting the money. A judgement is only a piece
of paper. It’s worth nothing if you can’t collect.
If what I have seen from Apple is any guide, they
will spend $50 Million to get out of paying my
four-figure judgement, simply out of spite. Just
how much of the shareholder’s money will Apple end
up spending because they tried to screw Seattle Rex
remains to be seen.
I’ll fight on, though. No matter how many obstacles
Apple throws in my way, I’ll keep going. After all,
it’s what I do. I guess you can say I …
Think Different.
Update: Wow, this article really set off a
firestorm. I’ve received scores of emails from
people who were given the same “it won’t boot so we
won’t repair it” explanation that I was, and were
forced to pay for the repair out of their own
pocket.
This really is a larger suit, perhaps a
class-action suit in the making (as much as I
detest class-actions for their unfairness toward
the class), and I am exploring the possibilities of
bringing a second suit against the company for
fraud, misrepresentation, etc.
I’m simply astounded by how many people received
the same treatment as myself over the 8600M issue.
Πηγή:
http://www.seattlerex.com/seattle-rex-vs-apple-the-verdict-is-in/