[11/29: Update added at the bottom of this post.
Also, the author was long YHOO and BABA at the time
of writing]
I am a big fan of both Apple and Tim Cook. I have
been for a while. I said Cook would do a great job
as CEO 6 months before Steve Jobs died and defended
his record 2 years ago when people were saying he
wasn’t “innovative” enough.
However, I do have a big problem with one choice
Cook has made over his tenure as CEO of Apple. It’s
not the lack of a bigger screen iPhone sooner or
his original choice of head of Apple Retail before
Angela Ahrendts. It’s his decision to spend $100
billion and counting of Apple cash on a capital
return program.
The program was announced in April 2012. It was the
first time since 1995 (before Jobs returned to the
company) that Apple had paid a dividend. To date,
it’s been estimated that Apple has used more than
$100 billion of its cash on dividends and stock
buybacks. To me, that’s madness.
Prior to Cook’s decision to start spending cash on
dividends and buybacks, Apple was content to let it
accumulate on its balance sheet. The company had
gone through a near death experience in 1997 and
obviously wanted to ensure it had a sufficient cash
cushion to continue to fund its operations in case
the markets ever turned against it.
By 2012, lots of Wall Street analysts had begun
complaining that Apple simply had too much cash
sitting idle on its balance sheet and it should
either invest it through R&D or M&A or
return it to shareholders.
There are generally 3 points of view regarding
Cook’s decision to start this capital return
program:
(1) Carl Icahn and most other observers affiliated
with Wall Street think it was smart and, if
anything, hasn’t gone far enough.
(2) Chamath Palihapitiya – a former Facebook (FB)
exec who is now a venture investor and a part-owner
of the Golden State Warriors basketball team – and
most tech people affiliated with Silicon Valley
think it was dumb and signals that the company
believes it has run out of areas to innovate in.
(3) Apple blogger John Gruber thinks there’s no
harm no foul in spending money on the dividends and
buybacks and supports not spending money
excessively on M&A because part of Apple’s
success has been staying focused – “a thousand no’s
for every yes.”
I believe the capital return program has been a
total waste of Apple’s hard-earned $100 billion. I
believe – although this is impossible to prove –
that Apple’s stock price would be just as high as
it is today (or more likely higher) had they spent
that $100 billion on a combination of smart M&A
and smart R&D that would have continued to
extend Apple’s lead over other Android phone
makers.
Had Apple not spent any money on a capital return
plan, it would now have over $255 billion in cash
on its balance sheet – a quarter of a trillion
dollars.
If I had a chance to have a coffee today with Tim
Cook and he still had $250 billion (with access to
much more zero interest cash through debt which
he’s only used to date for funding the capital
return plan), I would suggest he do five things
before Monday morning:
Buy Tesla (TSLA) for $45 billion (representing a
50% premium over yesterday’s closing price) – and
before he complained that that’s too much money,
I’d point out that if he’d listened to me on
February 20th and bought Tesla, it would have been
16% less that what he has to pay now.
Buy Twitter (TWTR) for $39 billion (representing a
50% premium over yesterday’s closing price) –
unfortunately that’s 4x what it would have cost
Apple to buy Twitter back in April 2012 when I
suggested to just after Facebook (FB) had bought
Instagram for $1 billion.
Buy Pinterest for $15 billion (a 50% premium over
what the private company is rumored to now be
worth, although it might be more now).
Spend $10 billion on better batteries through
R&D. To be fair, you’d get some of this already
through the Tesla acquisition. But is there
anything more frustrating to current iPhone users
than poor battery life?
Spend another $10 billion on other materials or
features which are going to corner the market on
some features that consumers will love yet will be
difficult for Android makers to copy. How about $10
billion just to make iCloud work properly?
Altogether, this M&A and R&D spree would
cost Apple $119 billion. Their cash levels would be
$136 billion today instead of $155 billion. They
wouldn’t have much revenue to show for that $119
billion but how much higher would Apple’s market
cap be than the $700 billion it is today? If Apple
owned Tesla, Twitter and Pinterest? That would be
worth at least another $50 – 100 billion in stock
value.
It seems like many on Wall Street believe the
capital return program is the reason for the
renewed vigor in Apple’s stock price which is up
48% this year alone. They say that new kinds of
institutional investors plus widow and orphan type
retail investors have been attracted to now own
Apple stock because of the dividend yield they
receive.
However, recall that the capital return program was
announced in the Spring of 2012. Apple’s stock
price initially dropped in the first few weeks
afterwards. It then rushed up through September
2012 to all-time highs before losing half its
value. The stock price bottomed out in mid-2013 and
only really started taking off this year after a
very bullish April earnings report.
Correlation is not causation. It’s not the Apple
capital return program that made people want to buy
(or sell) the stock. Rather, it’s Apple’s product
cycle, margins, and top-line revenue growth.
Two years ago, people worried that Apple was a
“hits-based” business relying on new phones each
year. It seemed like margins had peaked and
Cassandras were shouting that no consumer
electronics company – certainly not one without
Steve Jobs any more – could keep competitors from
eating away at that margin. Samsung seemed ready to
ascend to Apple’s throne. Tim Cook seemed to be a
care-taker.
Sentiment about Apple the stock didn’t change
because they started paying a dividend in my view.
Sentiment turned around when Apple kept crushing
earnings, people realized that the Apple ecosystem
was a lot stickier than first thought, and Eddy Cue
said in May that Apple had a product roadmap which
was the best he’d seen in the last 25 years.
It’s always been the product which has driven
Apple’s stock and always will be.
The day Apple decided to get on the treadmill of
paying out money to investors forever through
dividends and buybacks is that day they admitted to
the world that they can’t walk and chew gum at the
same time. A lot of potential innovation inside
Apple died that day.
John Gruber – whom I respect immensely, and who
humorously referred to me as “Action Jackson” for
imploring Apple to “do something” with their cash –
defended Cook’s decision to do the capital
allocation because (A) he thought it was smart for
Apple to adhere to a policy of focus over
willy-nilly acquisitions and (B) he believed it
would be marginally positive for the stock which
helps with employee retention. (I’m going by memory
from a Twitter exchange I had with Gruber 9 months
ago, but I’m pretty sure that was his reasoning.)
Here’s why I think John Gruber is wrong on this
issue. Anti-M&A Apple enthusiasts always say
that, because Apple has never done big
acquisitions, and Apple has been successful, Apple
therefore shouldn’t do acquisitions. This is mixing
correlation with causation again though in my view.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with acquisitions.
They have to be value-enhancing and help extend the
business in a direction it wants to go. If done
right, they can be very value-enhancing. Don’t
forget: Apple itself wouldn’t exist in its present
form had it not been for an acquisition – the 1996
acquisition of NeXT Software for $400 million,
returning Steve Jobs to Apple. I’d say that was a
good use of $400 million versus if they’d simply
paid it out in a dividend.
Even Apple seems to acknowledge this logic of the
benefit of big acquisitions with its recent $3
billion buy of Beats to supplement its iTunes
business.
In terms of the focus argument, Apple has about
45,000 non-retail employees today which is about
the same number as Google (GOOG). If Apple bought
Tesla, Twitter, and Pinterest, they’d gain 9,000
additional employees (although surely there’d be
some redundancies here – 5800 for Tesla, 3000 for
Twitter, 200 for Pinterest). That’s about a 20%
increase in headcount. I think a company like Apple
can surely handle that and keep its focus. I just
don’t think things are so sacrosanct at Apple that
they can’t manage these additional people.
Oh and I’m not alone in pushing for Apple to buy
Tesla (which would represent 5,800 of the new 6,100
employees Apple would gain through the 3
acquisitions I’m advocating). Chamath is – I think
— the guy who originally argued for this deal. John
Gruber agreed with my idea of buying Tesla. Jay
Yarow of Business Insider also recently extended my
original argument. So, we’re all in agreement that
this would be a brilliant – and frankly
breath-taking – acquisition Cook should make. In
some ways, it would very much resemble the NeXT
deal and how important Musk could be inside Apple
the way Jobs was.
Now, I’ve argued that Apple should make other
acquisitions in the past. Some will say here goes
“Action Jackson” again. But let’s review what I
said.
I argued in the past that Apple should buy Yahoo
(YHOO) for $23 billion back when Yahoo’s market cap
was $18 billion. Now Yahoo’s market cap is $50
billion. I believed that deal would have helped
given Apple some real web services which it still
is lacking, plus a great partner in China through
owning (what at that time would have been) 40% of
Alibaba (BABA).
I also argued that Apple should have bought
Facebook for $100 billion back in 2011 when it was
being privately valued at $50 billion and critics
were screaming that was way too expensive.
Would all of these deals shown a lack of focus?
Apple’s still doing something – who knows what? –
with iAd. They’re putting some focus there. If
you’re going to do that, why not have just bought
Facebook for $100 billion and let Mark Zuckerberg
continue to run it (if he would have accepted
Cook’s offer). You don’t have to worrying about
losing your focus. You’re paying Zuck $100 billion
to have focus for you over that asset. (And
wouldn’t Google have just hated Apple had they had
the moxie to do this?)
Apple’s still focusing on web services and messing
around with that area – not impressively. If
they’re going to devote some focus there, why not
just own Yahoo and have Marissa Mayer run that area
for them? Oh and they would have acquired a 40%
interest in Alibaba which is today worth $112
billion (pre-tax).
And, while it wasn’t something I argued for at the
time, you can understand now what the value to
Apple would have been if they’d bought Dropbox for
“nine figures” (which is less than $1 billion for
those math-challenged) back in 2009. Why did Steve
Jobs stubbornly push back from the table and say
Dropbox’s price was too high? Every time I interact
with iCloud, I curse the day Jobs got cheap and
thought Apple was better off staying focused and
not buying Dropbox.
So, please don’t lecture me about focus when I
criticize the folly of Apple for being too “stand
pat.” Apple – and only Apple due to its size and
cash balances at the time – could have spent $124
billion on Facebook, Dropbox and Yahoo and today
control assets worth $338 billion (just for
Facebook’s equity value, Dropbox’s estimated $10
billion in value, and the 40% stake in Alibaba).
That means Apple would already be a trillion dollar
company today easy.
Apple’s still focusing on iAd and web services
today and they’ve still blown $100 billion on
dividends and buybacks but they don’t have anything
to show for it. Let’s not try and defend these lack
of decisions as Tim Cook being focused or a
thousand no’s for every yes.
Apple could have a quarter of a trillion dollars
today in cash to put to work today. They could
become the overnight leader in smart cars by buying
Tesla. They could – more importantly – acquire our
generation’s single greatest technological leader
in Elon Musk and give him carte blanche to paint
his canvas. (Somehow, I think Musk could find a
better use of $100 billion than handing it over to
shareholders.) They could acquire the single most
unique and intriguing asset in the social
networking world today in Twitter which, despite
the recent management criticisms, is only going to
be more important to our culture moving forward.
They could acquire the single greatest threat to
Google search in the last 15 years by buying
Pinterest.
Tim Cook could make all this happen before we
return to work from Thanksgiving next Monday. He
could make Apple – a fundamentally great company –
into a remarkably exciting company unlike any other
in the world.
He should do this, but I doubt he will.
I doubt he will because he’s married a fickle lover
in Wall Street. He’s paid Wall Street $100 billion
to date and promised countless more billions in the
future. This doesn’t make Apple a better company or
promise a brighter future. And it doesn’t raise the
stock any higher than it would rise anyway on the
hopes of the latest round of new products.
There are times I agree companies should pay out
cash to shareholders in dividends or buybacks
instead of doing pointless M&A. I’d rather see
Yahoo do that right now than spend billions more on
another Tumblr and 3 dozen nameless acqui-hire
companies.
But Apple can do much better for itself now with
its billions rather than continue wasting them on
nameless, faceless Wall Street mutual fund
managers. No one else can put $100 billion to use
on M&A and R&D other than Apple to
transform itself for the better.
Only Apple can spend $100 billion wisely.
It’s time for Tim Cook to think different.
Update [11/29]: Comments and tweets are running
about 99 to 1 anti-Eric’s argument above. I
basically have Jay Yarow (partially) in my corner
and some random guy on Twitter and that’s it.
However, I want to add to the argument above based
on the reaction so far.
1. I would rather have seen Apple keep $100 billion
over the last 2.5 years instead of paying it out to
shareholders. Either you agree with me or you shrug
your shoulders and say “what’s the big deal?” I
think it is a big deal. It’s $100 billion! That’s
nothing to shrug your shoulders at. It took Apple
as a company a lifetime to be in the fortunate
position to have generated that much capital and I
think they should have kept it than paid it out. At
the least, they should stop this capital return
plan and keep everything from here.
I don’t think Apple’s stock price would be any
different today with our without the capital payout
program. I can’t prove that obviously but, guess
what? Neither can those saying it is perfectly
correlated to the recent rise in Apple’s stock
price.
Apple’s stock initially dropped after they
announced their plan in 2012. Wall Street never
perfectly prices in what it perhaps it economically
should. That’s why – for years – Wall Street didn’t
seem to give any credit for the cash Apple was
accumulating.
There are lots of companies who do buybacks and
dividends and it seems to benefit those companies.
But they’re generally not innovative ones. They’re
generally at the top of their S-curved growth.
I believe the most important determinant of Apple’s
stock price – two years ago and now – is how
investors perceive the coming cycle of new Apple
products. In my view, that’s what caused the 50%
drop in Apple’s price two years ago (on a negative
perception of that coming cycle) and it’s what’s
caused the recent ramp up this year in the stock
(on a positive perception). The dividends and
buybacks are correlated with the stock’s rise
recently but not the cause – in my view.
2. I think there are many tech-minded people who
believe that the day your company starts paying a
dividend is the day you say “I can’t think of
anything creative to do with the money myself so
I’m going to give it back to the shareholders.”
Again, it suggests you’re at the top of the S-curve
and you’re simply going to milk your profits from
here on out.
There are lots of ways Apple could still grow. I
think few who argue against that. I’d rather see
Apple keep all its cash ready to attack those
problems through R&D or M&A.
3. The Focus thing. For me to mention buying Tesla,
Twitter, Pinterest, Yahoo, Dropbox, and Facebook in
the post, I think it came across that I was arguing
to do all those acquisitions and more big ones in
the future at the drop of a hat. Any of those deals
would have made financial sense but I recognize
that cultural fit is important.
Apple might have looked at buying Yahoo 2 years
ago. They might have believed it was attractive to
own 40% of Alibaba years before folks were talking
about it here and the potential ways Alibaba could
help them in China, but they still might have
decided against buying Yahoo because of the
potential headache digesting 13,000 Yahoo employees
who had been running on auto-pilot for years.
So, yes, cultural fit is important. And, yes, none
of those companies might not have agreed to sell –
like Zuckerberg. But Apple is still doing stuff in
ads. They are focusing there. Either get in or get
out of the pool. Do ads or not. And, if you’re
going to do ads, you probably need some help. So
acquire someone (else, because they’ve done some
alread). You’ve got ample cash unlike any other
company in the world so go for it. If you’re going
to play around with Ping, go all the way with it.
Of all the potential acquisitions I suggested, I
think the most interesting by far is Tesla. If I
was Cook, that’s the first one I’d do. If it was
the only one he did, I’d be happy.
I still think Twitter and Pinterest could also be
huge assets in the future for Apple so I’d also
grab them now at lower prices than what they’ll be
in 5 years and I’d get to work on integrating them
now rather than waiting and having more of an
integration issue later.
4. Why did Cook choose to do the dividend and
payout? I think that’s worth thinking about. Sure
he was getting pressure from David Einhorn and Carl
Icahn to do it but I don’t think either of those
guys (who I respect) forced Tim to do it. I believe
Cook thought Apple had way too much money than it
could spend and this was a way to increase the
stock price. He seemed to go out of his way when
the stock dropped in 2013 to buy more stock to aid
the stock price. I think he probably worried that a
low stock price would hurt employee morale and
retention. So, I think it came from a “it can’t
hurt, only help” place for Cook. And, by the way, I
think Cook’s a great leader and any one who’s read
my stuff for years knows I defended him when others
– who really knew nothing – were calling for his
head.
However, despite this all coming from a good place,
I think Cook simply misjudged what drives Apple’s
stock price. It’s the product cycle, period. So,
this $100 billion has been wasted and I think it
could have been better spent.
5. Apple shouldn’t be doing big acquisitions every
year. But they should be thinking “what’s the NeXT
acquisition we could do today which would propel
our company into a totally new and exciting vector
that makes sense?” I think Tesla is it for reasons
I’ve argued before.
6. People talk about Apple’s patience, its focus,
its culture as things that have led to its success.
They worry that doing a big acquisition might hurt
Apple’s specialness.
I think it’s obvious Apple has a dominant bias to
build vs. buy. That’s fine, but I think those
biases – which have made it a very special company
– can also sow the seeds of future mistakes. The
concern I have with Apple is that it is missing a
big transformational acquisition – Tesla for
example – because it defaults back to these biases
(that’s too big, we don’t do that, a thousand no’s
for every yes) and misses a huge opportunity.
7. Maybe Apple’s worried about falling into an
anti-trust trap with the government like has
happened to Microsoft and Google. Maybe that’s the
real reason they’re avoiding big acquisitions
today. That’s fair. But I can’t see how a Tesla
acquisition would concern antitrust regulators.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/ericjackson/2014/11/27/apples-100-billion-waste-tim-cooks-single-biggest-mistake-as-ceo/2/