Apple CEO Tim Cook tells Investors Who Care
More About Return on Investment than Climate
Change: Your Money is No Longer Welcome.
As Board Member Al Gore Cheers the Tech Giant’s
Dedication to Environmental Activism, Investors
Left to Wonder Just How Much Shareholder Value is
Being Destroyed in Efforts to Combat “Climate
Change”.
Free-Market Activist Presents Shareholder
Resolution to Computer Giant Apple Calling for
Consumer Transparency on Environmental Issues;
Company Balks.
Cupertino, CA / Washington, D.C. – At today’s
annual meeting of Apple shareholders in Cupertino,
California, Apple CEO Tim Cook informed investors
that are primarily concerned with making reasonable
economic returns that their money is no longer
welcome.
The message came in response to the National Center
for Public Policy Research’s shareholder resolution
asking the tech giant to be
transparent about its environmental activism and a
question from the National Center about the
company’s environmental initiatives.
“Mr. Cook made it very clear to me that if I, or
any other investor, was more concerned with return
on investment than reducing carbon dioxide
emissions, my investment is no longer welcome at
Apple,” said
Justin
Danhof, Esq., director of the
National Center’s Free Enterprise Project.
Danhof also asked Apple CEO Tim Cook about the
company’s green energy pursuits. Danhof asked
whether the company’s environmental investments
increased or decreased the company’s bottom line.
After initially suggesting that the investments
make economic sense, Cook said the company would
pursue environmental goals even if there was no
economic point at all to the venture. Danhof
further asked if the company’s projects would
continue to make sense if the federal government
stopped heavily subsidizing alternative energy.
Cook completely ignored the inquiry and became
visibly agitated.
Danhof went on to ask if Cook was willing to amend
Apple’s corporate documents to indicate that the
company would not pursue environmental initiatives
that have some sort of reasonable return on
investment – similar to the
concession the National Center recently received
from General Electric. This question
was greeted by boos and hisses from the Al gore
contingency in the room.
“Here’s the bottom line: Apple is as obsessed with
the theory of so-called climate change as its board
member Al Gore is,” said Danhof. “The company’s CEO
fervently wants investors who care more about
return on investments than reducing CO2 emissions
to no longer invest in Apple. Maybe they should
take him up on that advice.”
“Although the National Center’s proposal did not
receive the required votes to pass, millions of
Apple shareholders now know that the company is
involved with organizations that don’t appear to
have the best interest of Apple’s investors in
mind,” said Danhof. “Too often investors look at
short-term returns and are unaware of corporate
policy decisions that may affect long-term
financial prospects. After today’s meeting,
investors can be certain that Apple is wasting
untold amounts of shareholder money to combat
so-called climate change. The only remaining
question is: how much?”
The National Center’s shareholder resolution noted
that “[s]ome trade associations and business
organizations have expanded beyond the promotion of
traditional business goals and are lobbying
business executives to pursue objectives with
primarily social benefits. This may affect Company
profitability and shareholder value. The Company’s
involvement and acquiescence in these endeavors
lacks transparency, and publicly-available
information about the Company’s trade association
memberships and related activities is minimal. An
annual report to shareholders will help protect
shareholder value.”
Apple’s full 2014 proxy statement is available
here. The National Center’s
proposal, “Report on Company Membership and
Involvement with Certain Trade Associations and
Business Organizations,” appears on page 60.
The National Center filed the resolution, in part,
because of Apple’s membership in the Retail
Industry Leaders Association (RILA), one of the
country’s largest trade associations. In its 2013
“Retail Sustainability Report,” RILA
states: “Companies will often
develop individual or industry voluntary programs
to reduce the need for government regulations. If a
retail company minimizes its waste generation,
energy and fuel usage, land-use footprint, and
other environmental impacts, and strives to improve
the labor conditions of the workers across its
product supply chains, it will have a competitive
advantage when regulations are developed.”
“This shows that rather than fighting increased
government regulation, RILA is cooperating with
Washington, D.C.’s stranglehold on American
business in a misguided effort to stop so-called
climate change,” said Danhof. “That is not an
appropriate role for a trade association.”
For even more information on RILA, read
“
The
Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA): A
Cartel that Threatens Innovation and
Competitiveness,” by National Center
Senior Fellow
Dr.
Bonner Cohen.
“Rather than opting for transparency, Apple opposed
the National Center’s resolution,” noted Danhof.
“
Apple’s
actions, from hiring of President
Obama’s former head of the Environmental Protection
Agency Lisa Jackson, to its investments in
supposedly 100 percent renewable data centers, to
Cook’s antics at today’s meeting, appear to be
geared more towards combating so-called climate
change rather than developing new and innovative
phones and computers.”
After Danhof presented the proposal, a
representative of CalPERS rose to object and stated
that climate change should be one of corporate
America’s primary concerns, and after she called
carbon dioxide emissions a “mortal danger,” Apple
board member and former vice president Al Gore
turned around and loudly clapped and cheered.
“If Apple wants to follow Al Gore and his chimera
of climate change, it does so at its own peril,”
said Danhof. “Sustainability and the free market
can work in concert, but not if Al Gore is
directing corporate behavior.”
“Tim Cook, like every other American, is entitled
to his own political views and to be an activist of
any legal sort he likes on his own time,” said Amy
Ridenour, chairman of the National Center for
Public Policy Research. “And if Tim Cook, private
citizen, does not care that over 95 percent of all
climate models have over-forecast the extent of
predicted global warming, and wishes to use those
faulty models to lobby for government policies that
raise prices, kill jobs and retard economic growth
and extended lifespans in the Third World, he has a
right to lobby as he likes. But as the CEO of a
publicly-held corporation, Tim Cook has a
responsibility to, consistent with the law, to make
money for his investors. If he’d rather be CEO of
the Sierra Club or Greenpeace, he should apply.”
“As in the past, Cook took but a handful of
questions from the many shareholders present who
were eager to ask a question at the one meeting a
year in which shareholder questions are taken,”
added Ridenour, “leaving many disappointed.
Environmentalism may be a byword at Apple, but
transparency surely is not.”
The National Center’s
Free
Enterprise Project is a leading
free-market corporate activist group. In 2013, Free
Enterprise Project representatives attended 33
shareholder meetings advancing free-market ideals
in the areas of health care, energy, taxes,
subsidies, regulations, religious freedom, media
bias, gun rights and many more important public
policy issues. Today’s Apple meeting was the
National Center’s third attendance at a shareholder
meeting so far in 2014.
The National Center for Public Policy Research is
an Apple shareholder, as are National Center
executives.
The National Center for Public Policy Research,
founded in 1982, is a non-partisan, free-market,
independent conservative think-tank. Ninety-four
percent of its support comes from individuals, less
than four percent from foundations, and less than
two percent from corporations. It receives over
350,000 individual contributions a year from over
96,000 active recent contributors.
http://wattsupwiththat.com/2014/03/02/mind-blowing-apple-ceo-tells-deniers-to-get-out-of-apple-stock/