Apple released OS X Yosemite. By now you should
recognize this as a familiar refrain from yours
truly, but I'm going to say it anyway: Don't
upgrade. Just don't do it. At least not yet.
Yosemite's been in developers' hands since June,
when it was announced at Apple's WWDC event in San
Francisco, and it's also been in the public's hands
— in the form of a public beta version that's been
iterated several times since its release this
summer.
So I, for one, am hoping for a more stable release
than we saw of Mavericks, which took months to sort
out after it made its debut last fall.
But I'm not counting on it.
Ever since iOS 8 dropped in September there's been
incessant chatter on tech blogs
armchair-quarterbacking Apple's internal
development processes. I've also seen at least a
few blogs suggest that Apple's quality assurance
measures have gone downhill; that Apple's no longer
focusing on quality. Some have even hauled out the
well-worn "This never would have happened with
Steve Jobs" trope that's been beaten to death since
his passing in 2011.
It's all bullshit.
Apple's QA has been a lot worse. Just ask any of us
old Mac vets who lived through the "Classic" Mac OS
days. And there were a few stinkers on the OS X
road too.
Certainly stuff like iOS 8.0.1 shouldn't have
happened - killing your new flagship product with
an over the air update was just baffling, and I
hope some day to learn the story of just how that
got out the door.
But the fact is that iOS and OS X are both complex,
intricate systems. And Apple has a pretty
aggressive update schedule that brings major new
versions of its operating systems each year.
Sometimes it takes a bit of time for Apple to shake
out the problems.
The problem as I see it is that Apple has now made
it trivially easy for many of us to upgrade the
second we get a notification, so upgrade we do.
Anyone on the bleeding edge of an upgrade who
experiences problems is likely to complain about
it, and social media makes it simple for us to find
like-minded people and band together. Even Apple's
own discussion forums sometimes give us a distorted
sense of the magnitude of technical problems we
have with our Apple products.
Before I wrote I had a career in IT, and it was
drilled into me by my bosses that we should never
be on the bleeding edge of anything because doing
so carries risk, and risk costs us profitability.
It was a problem, sometimes, because vendors
promised the moon if we'd just agree to upgrade our
software or hardware. The temptation is to increase
productivity — and therefore profits.
That risk aversion is easy to lose when it's not a
question of making money, but just of having the
newest thing you can. It's easy when Apple releases
the software updates for free, too.
It's especially compelling this year, because many
Mac users have iOS devices too, and already have
upgraded to iOS 8 or may have purchased a new
device that already has iOS 8 installed on it. And
iOS 8 and Yosemite sport benefits together — in the
form of Apple's "Handoff" technology — that promise
an experience greater than the sum of their parts.
But if your Mac is stable and working well enough
right now with Mavericks, I'd caution you to
consider waiting just a little bit of time before
upgrading to Yosemite. You really ought to wait and
see where the pitfalls are before you jump.
Some of you are reading this and scoffing. You've
been using the public beta and you see no reason to
wait. Or you really want or need those Handoff
features to work right. Or you mistakenly upgraded
to iCloud Drive when you switched to iOS 8 and you
want to get access to your iCloud documents again.
Before you start crafting an angry retort scoffing
at my suggestion, please understand that my advice
is not offered as a one-size-fits-all
recommendation to everyone — just to those of you
reading this who may not have a compelling reason
(or think you know better). For those of you, just
hang on a bit and see where the problems lie. Then
decide when it's time to make the jump to Yosemite.