Apple violates German data protection law by asking
for users’ broad, overall consent in its privacy
policy, the Regional Court of Berlin ruled.
Apple’s terms for sharing personal information with
the company are too broadly formulated, the court
ruled on April 30, according to a verdict published
by the Federation of German Consumer Organisations
(VZBV) on Tuesday.
The VZBV demanded in 2011 that Apple Sales
International should stop using unfair contractual
clauses in its privacy policy as posted on its
German website, said Helke Heidemann-Peuser, a
lawyer and head of the VZBV’s legal enforcement
section. After this warning, Apple committed to
change five of those clauses, but this was not
enough, which is why the VZBV decided to sue Apple
in February 2012, she said.
After Apple was sued, the company committed to
change two more clauses, after which the lawsuit
continued over the eight remaining disputed
clauses, said Heidemann-Peuser. The court found
that Apple violates the law with all those clauses,
she added.
In its German privacy policy, which is similar to
the one used in the U.S., Apple states for instance
that when someone contacts Apple and its
affiliates, they may share information about that
person with each other. Apple also states that this
information may be combined with other information
to provide and improve products, services, content
and advertising.
This clause violates the law because customers are
unaware which data is used and to what extend, the
court ruled, according to the VZBV.
Another problematic clause gives Apple the right to
collect the information someone provides about
friends and family such as name, mailing address,
email address and phone number when someone sends a
gift certificate or products or invites others to
join a user on an Apple forum, Heidemann-Peuser
said. This is illegal because Apple would need
consent from the third party to process this data,
she said.
Apple also states that it may collect, use and
share precise location data, including the
real-time geographic location of a users’ Apple
computer or device, in order to provide location
based services like advertising on Apple products.
The data, as collected, is anonymous, according to
Apple’s policy. However, when location-based
services are used, the data can always be traced
back to an individual, according to the court, so
this clause was also prohibited.
Apple now needs to change these clauses, said
Heidemann-Peuser. “They need to be very specific,”
she said, adding that Apple needs to ask for users’
explicit consent instead of letting them agree to
an overly broad privacy policy.
However, the company does not need to do so
immediately because Apple can appeal the verdict,
which the VZBV expects the company to do.
Apple did not reply to a request for comment.
Πηγή:
MacWorld